From the recordings What Makes It Christmas? and What Makes It Christmas?
"What Makes It Christmas?"
Music and Lyrics by Johnny Schaefer
Produced by Stephan Oberhoff
Associate Producer, Johnny Schaefer
Executive Producer, Johnny Schaefer
Arranged by Stephan Oberhoff and Johnny Schaefer
© Copyright, 2026, Johnny Schaefer, Auditory Verve Music, ASCAP
John Herbert Schaefer
All RIghts Reserved
Lead Vocals: Johnny Schaefer
Supporting Vocals: Johnny Schaefer and Stephan Oberhoff
All instruments played by Stephan Oberhoff
Recorded by Stephan Oberhoff, Creation Station East
Mixed and Mastered by Stephan Oberhoff
Cover Design by Johnny Schaefer and Marge Walsh
Photograph by Paco Silva
Lyrics
What Makes It Christmas?
Music and Lyrics by Johnny Schaefer
Verse 1
They say it wasn’t Winter
It wasn’t even cold
So many variations to the stories that we’re told
What is it that you long for
When Christmas time is near?
What is it that you need to see?
What do you need to hear to make it real?
What makes it real?
What makes it feel like Christmas?
Chorus
We need hope
We need light
We need singing in the night
We need peace
We need cheer
We need to love the ones most near to make it Christmas
Love makes it Christmas
Love makes it Christmas
Verse 2
The world can feel like Winter
Even when it’s warm
And words can feel like icicles
That suddenly get formed
When mad winds begin to blow
Where’s Christmas when it’s dark?
What shining light will make things clear?
What friendly voices will we hear to make it real?
What makes it real?
What makes it feel like Christmas?
Chorus
Bridge
An act of love
Selfless and pure
Musi be extended to endure
Simple Christmas love is sure to bring us joy
Chorus
Love Makes it Christmas
© Copyright 2026, Johnny Schaefer Auditory Verve Music (John Herbert Schaefer, ASCAP)
