What Makes it Christmas? This song came from conversations Johnny Schaefer had with family and friends during the holidays who kept saying, "It just doesn't feel like Christmas." That got him thinking about historians who say that the actual event likely did not occur in the Winter. So, What Makes it Christmas? Johnny does have an answer that is heartwarming and real. To record the track, Johnny traveled to Stephan Oberhoff's Creation Station, East near Nashville, TN. Credits Music and Lyrics by Johnny Schaefer © Copyright 2026, Johnny Schaefer (John Herbert Schaefer) Auditory Verve Music, ASCAP All Rights Reserved Worldwide Produced by Stephan Oberhoff and Johnny Schaefer Executive Producer, Johnny Schaefer
Arranged by Stephan Oberhoff and Johnny Schaefer
Lead Vocal by Johnny Schaefer
Supporting Vocals by Johnny Schaefer and Stephan Oberhoff
All Instruments played and recorded by Stephan Oberhoff
Engineered, Recorded, Mixed and Mastered by Stephan Oberhoff, Creation Station, East
Cover design by Johnny Schaefer and Marge Walsh
Photography by Paco Silva
Music Video Produced and Directed by Paco Silva
Video filmed at 9 Vyris, Los Angeles
Hair by Cathy Spiramong, Tangles Salon, Pasadena
Makeup by Olive
Follow and listen on Spotify Apple Music Tidal Pandora Amazon Music iheartRadio YouTube Deezer Soundcloud Blue Sky Facebook Instagram Tik Tok
Hear Johnny on the Big Blend Radio and Magazines Podcast
Johnny Schaefer’s @hearjohnny YouTube channel has more than 4 million views worldwide. Subscribe to keep up to date
www.hearjohnny.com